The petition notes: "The Clean Air Act's Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) program requires EPA to undertake annual notice-and-comment rule making to determine a 'renewable fuel obligation' for the nation's transportation fuel supply. The first of three annual 'required elements' is to determine the point of obligation -- i.e., to ensure that the obligation shall be applicable to refineries, blenders, and importers, as appropriate. EPA admits that it initially placed the point of obligation on refineries and importers, but not blenders, for reasons of administrative convenience. EPA has repeatedly refused to re-examine that placement in annual rule making, and it denied petitions for rule making seeking reconsideration out-side the statutorily-mandated annual assessment."
The petition specifically questions: whether the requirement that EPA "shall" make a "calendar year" determination of the "appropriate" point of obligation requires EPA to consider in each annual rule whether the point of obligation remains appropriate.The petition also questions whether EPA can evade the annual duty by partitioning the point of obligation into a one-time collateral proceeding that ignores key evidence,relies primarily on the agency's own convenience, and claims more deference from a reviewing court than an annual rule would receive. (Source: AFPM Website, Valero Energy, Ethanol Producer, 6 May, 2019) Contact: American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers, www.afpm.org; Valero Renewable Fuels, Joe Gorder, Pres., (800) 324-8464, www.valero.com
More Low-Carbon Energy News American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers , RFS, Point of Obligation, Valero Energy ,
As previously reported, "hardship waivers" were intended for refineries producing 75,000 bpd or less and suffered "disproportionate economic hardship" from the costs of RFS compliance.
The waiver frees the refineries from an obligation to provide the EPA with biofuels credits proving compliance. (Source: WHTC Radio, Reuters,3 April, 2018)
Contact: Andeavor, (210) 626-6000, www.andeavor.com; Philadelphia Energy Solutions, www.pes-companies.com
More Low-Carbon Energy News RFS, RINs, Biofuel Blend, Point of Obligation, Philadelphia Energy Solutions, RFS, EPA,
"While PES continues to blame the RFS for its woes, the fact is, the bankruptcy is a mess of its own making," said Kurt Kovarik, NBB's VP of Federal Affairs. "Poor management and a failure to respond to changes in the crude oil market is to blame. PES should not be rewarded for deliberately failing to comply with the decade-old Renewable Fuel Standard. Doing so is akin to rewarding a toddler in the midst of a temper tantrum. Instead, the government should hold PES to the same renewable volume obligation as all other refiners. Not doing so could severely hinder the RFS's goals of enhancing energy security, protecting the environment and building our nation’s rural economy."
NBB highlighted two key components in comments to the DOJ submitted March 26. First, the RFS holds parent companies liable for the compliance obligations of their subsidiaries. Thus, PES's corporate parents Carlyle and Sunoco can be required to comply with the RFS obligations incurred by PES. EPA has not explained why it is abandoning that avenue for ensuring complete fulfillment of PES's obligations. Second, the renewable volume obligations (RVOs) under the RFS cannot be discharged in bankruptcy. The RFS creates an affirmative duty for obligated parties to blend or use biofuels or to buy credits from others who have done so. Such a duty persists through the bankruptcy because it cannot be resolved by a payment to the government.
(Source: National Biodiesel Board, 27 Mar., 2018)
Contact: National Biodiesel Board, Kurt Kovarik, VP of Federal Affairs, 800) 841-5849, www.biodiesel.org; Philadelphia Energy Solutions, www.pes-companies.com
More Low-Carbon Energy News National Biodiesel Board, PES, Point of Obligation, RFS, Biofuel Blend, NBB, RFS,
As previously reported, PES' plan to exit it Chapter 11 bankruptcy is dependent upon its shedding existing biofuel "point-of-obligation" biofuel blending costs under the US DOE Renewable Fuels Standard.
The company claims its 2016-17 biofuels obligation totaled $185 million, and the cost of RINs in 2017 alone was $218 million, according to Reuters. (Source: PES, Reuters, Various Media, Feb., 2018) Contact: Philadelphia Energy Solutions, www.pes-companies.com
More Low-Carbon Energy News RFS, Point-of-Obligation, RINs, Ethanol, Ethanol BlendPhiladelphia Energy Solutions, RFS, Point of Obligation, EPA,
The EPA has the authority to grant exemptions from the program to small capacity refineries if the company can demonstrate financial hardship. but the agency has been reluctant to do so in the past.
In the four years ended in 2016, the agency reportedly granted a total of 29 small-refiner exemptions, according to data provided to Reuters by the EPA in response to a Freedom of Information Act request.
(Source: NASDAQ, Reuters, Others, 25 Jan., 2018)
More Low-Carbon Energy News RFS, Biofuel Blend,
In its decision released Wednesday, EPA said "a change in the point of obligation would unnecessarily increase the complexity of the program and undermine the success of the RFS program."
Iowas Sen. Chuck Grassley (R) said "Keeping the point of obligation where it is now, with refiners and importers, has worked and makes sense. Moving the point of obligation from a handful of refiners to hundreds or thousands of small fuel retailers would undermine the integrity and viability of this successful program."
The EPA is slated to announce the volume requirements -- the amount of biofuels that must be blended with the nation's fuel supply -- by the end of the month.
In July, EPA proposed volume requirements for cellulosic biofuel, advanced biofuel and total renewable fuel that are lower than 2017 requirements.
(Source: EPA, The Des Moines Register, 24 Nov., 2017) Contact: Sen. Chuck Grassley, https://twitter.com/ChuckGrassley
More Low-Carbon Energy News Renewable Fuel Standard, Biofuel Blend, RFS EPA, Point of Obligation,
The proposed changes were widely opposed by farm-state legislators and ethanol producers.
The EPA's formal declaration satisfies EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt's pledge to retain the current structure of the RFS requiring refiners and importers to blend biofuels into petroleum transportation fuels.
Refiners are reportedly affected unevenly by the current mandate -- those without sufficient infrastructure to blend in biofuels themselves must instead buy credits to comply while other companies that blend transportation fuels, but do not own refineries and therefore are not required to satisfy annual biofuel quotas, can sell those tradable credits.
(Source: EPA, Industry Week, Bloomberg, 23 Nov., 2017)
Contact: Valero Energy, (800) 324-8464, www.valero.com; EPA Scott Pruitt, www.facebook.com/EPAScottPruitt; www.epa.gov/aboutepa/about-office-administrator
More Low-Carbon Energy News RFS, EPA, Scott Pruitt, Valero, Point of Obligation,
Biofuels producers have claimed that shifting the 'point of obligation' away from refiners would cause "years of industry upheaval." The American Petroleum Institute (API) has opposed the change, saying it would be a "distraction from the kind of overhaul or full-on repeal the program needs."
(Sourc: EPA, FSM News, Others, 4 Aug., 2017)
More Low-Carbon Energy News RFS, Biofuel Blend, Point of Obligation, EPA, API,
The video is intended to dispel the widespread confusion created within the marketplace by a handful of merchant refiners and investors who have petitioned the EPA to shift the compliance requirements. Doing so would undercut RFS efforts to sustain the use of renewable fuels in gasoline and diesel fuel, according to the video.
NACS, NATSO, SIGMA and a coalition of more than 35 organizations and companies representing the entire fuel supply chain, from refiners to retailers to renewable fuels groups, oppose shifting the compliance responsibility on the grounds that it would create disruption in the marketplace and ultimately raise prices at the pump.
(Source: NACS, 23 May, 2017) Contact: NATSO, Lisa Mullings, Pres., CEO, David Fialkov, VP Gov. Affairs, (703) 549-2100, www.natso.com; NACS, www.nacsonline.com; SIGMA, www.sigma.org;
More Low-Carbon Energy News Biofuel Blend, Point of Obligation, NATSO, SIGMA, NACS,
"The challenge facing the Nebraska ethanol industry today is access to the consumer. RFN supports measures that would eliminate barriers to the increased sale of E15 and open new markets for domestic renewable fuels."
RFN represents ethanol producers in the state of Nebraska, which produces approximately 2.5 billion gpy at 25 plants. (Source: Renewable Fuels Nebraska, Mar., 2017) Contact: Renewable Fuels Nebraska, Mark Palmer, Exec. Dir., www.ethanolrfa.org
More Low-Carbon Energy News Renewable Fuels Nebraska , Ethanol Blend, Ethanol, Point of Obligation,
The possible Executive Order is reportedly the culmination of a "backroom" deal between Trump Administration advisor Carl Icahn and the Renewable Fuels Association that would shift the obligation under the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) from refiners to fuel retailers.
A White House spokesperson reportedly denied rumors of a change to the ethanol mandate and said "there isn't an ethanol Executive Order in the works."
(Source: Association for Convenience & Fuel Retailing, Various Others, 1 Mar., 2017)
More Low-Carbon Energy News RFS, Point of Obligation, Biofuel Blend, Carl Ichan, Renewable Fuels Association,
The Renewable Fuels Assocoation (RFA) has come out in opposition to such a change. "We were told the point-of-obligation change was going to happen, whether we were involved or not," RFA Communication Director Rachel Gantz told DTN. "We wanted to make sure E15 RVP parity was addressed." Then, the RFA offered a statement from its President and Chief Executive Officer Bob Dinneen, who said his group remains opposed to changing the point of obligation. "We received a call from an official with the Trump administration, informing us that a pending executive order would change the point of obligation from refiners to position holders at the terminal, a potentially small increase in the number of obligated parties, but one which would distribute the obligation more equitably," Dinneen said. Dinneen added, "Despite our continued opposition to the move, we were told the executive order was not negotiable."
The Wall Street Journal reported on Tuesday quoted a White House spokesperson as saying "there are no pending executive orders related to ethanol." (Source: Various Sources, DTN Progressive Farmer, Mar., 2017)
More Low-Carbon Energy News RFS Point of Obligation,
In its initial rulemaking, the EPA defined an obligated party as a refiner or importer and explained then that they considered placing the point of obligation at the terminal. The EPA now says the RFS would be maintained, but responsibility for compliance would be shifted from refiners to fuel blenders.
Fuels America apparently took umbridge to RFA CEO Bob Dinneen's recent statement that the association "received a call from an official with the Trump administration" informing it that a pending White House order would remove oil refiner's obligation to blend ethanol with gasoline. (Source: Fuels Amercia, 2 Mar., 2017) Contact: Renewable Fuels Association, (202) 289-3835, www.ethanolrfa.org;
Fuels America Coalition, www.fuelsamerica.org
More Low-Carbon Energy News RFS, point of obligation, Fuels America, Renewable Fuels Association ,